Echeveria Harmsii vs. Pulvinata: 7 Main Differences

Echeverias are undeniably everyone’s favorite succulents. They have beautiful looks, patience, and maximum adaptability. This applies to two of the most popular varieties of this genus; Echeveria Harmsii and Pulvinata.

They are ideal houseplants that will make your interiors or exteriors extra beautiful. The main issue regarding the two lovely plants is their almost identical appearances.

Because they are so similar, many new collectors need clarification. They often mistake one plant for the other. If this is you, I’d like you to keep reading. This Echeveria Harmsii vs. Pulvinata blog post will discuss their differences and prominent characteristics widely.

Echeveria Harmsii vs. Pulvinata
The main differences between Echeveria Harmsii and Pulvinata are their leaf size, leaf shape, mature size, leaf density, stem features, flower size, and flowering seasons. Both plants have similar leaves, but those of the Echeveria Pulvinata are more on the oblong side.

What is Echeveria Harmsii?

Echeveria Harmsii is a highly sought-after ornamental plant native to Central America, particularly Mexico. This plant was named after a German botanist, Herman Harms. Echeveria Harmsii is highly prized for its foliage.

It has light to medium green leaves. The leaf tips are usually deep red. This plant is labeled a “plush plant” or “red Echeveria.”

Echeveria Harmsii, like the Graptosedum ghost plant, belongs to the Crassulaceae family. This plant is famous for having skinny, velvety leaves covered with soft fuzz. In terms of texture, the leaves are fleshy, like the vast majority of succulentsThe leaves have an oblanceolate shape.

When caring for this plant, you might not find real difficulty. It is an extremely patient plant. You don’t need to worry about watering schedules. Before watering, your plush plant must be nearly dehydrated.

You can leave this plant in direct sunlight without worrying about damage. Just avoid leaving it exposed to harsh rays during noontime.

What is Echeveria Pulvinata?

This is a highly preferred Echeveria variety. It is a beautiful succulent that is bought for its bright green foliage. The edges and top parts of these leaves are covered in pink or red shades.

The leaves are also covered in a thick layer of whitish fuzz. This layer adds softness and velvetiness to the plant. This fuzziness also increases the plant’s tolerance to drought.

Echeveria Pulvinata is commonly known as the chenille plant. Echeveria Pulvinata, like the plush plant, is native to Mexico. The plant is not a large grower.

It remains compact despite growing as a shrub. The leaves of the Chenille plant are obovate with fuzzy stems and prominent pointed tips.

Watering Echeveria Pulvinata won’t be a hassle. You can water it once every 10 days. Sometimes, it could take longer between each round of watering. During the cold season, you can reduce this succulent once every month.

Full sun is important for the healthy growth of this plant. Your Echeveria Pulvinata won’t tolerate cold weather, so you should not leave it below 18 degrees Celsius.

What are the Differences between Echeveria Harmsii and Pulvinata?

The first thought that comes to mind when encountering Echeveria Harmsii and Pulvinata is that they are the same plant. However, when you spend some time with both similar Echeveria varieties, you can start noticing the differences. 

Whenever you look at the leaves and stems, you can spot some of them.

1. Leaf size

The leaves of Echeveria Harmsii and Pulvinata are small. They are the same height, around 3 cm long. However, there is a slight difference in their width. The leaves of Echeveria Harmsii are a bit broader.

The Echeveria Harmsii are around 3.5 cm wide, whereas those of Echeveria are approximately 2 cm wide. But generally, the leaves of Echeveria Harmsii are narrower at the base.

2. Leaf shape

If you observe the shapes of both leaves, you can see a noticeable difference. The leaves of Echeveria Harmsii are obovate. This means the leaves have a reversed ovate shape.

The leaves of Harmsii Pulvinata, on the other hand, are oblanceolate. This means these leaves have a reversed lanceolate shape.

3. Mature size

The mature size of both plants is nearly similar. On the other hand, a fully grown Echeveria Harmsii spreads a little wider. Both plants reach a height of 30 cm.

A mature Echeveria Pulvinata spreads around 11 cm wide, whereas a mature Echeveria Harmsii spreads approximately 31 cm wide.

4. Leaves density

While both plants have almost identical leaves, they have different densities. Echeveria Pulvinata has denser leaves. The Echeveria Harmsii seems to lose its leaves more frequently, making it look less dense.

5. Stem features

One of the most obvious signs in the Echeveria Harmsii vs. Pulvinata comparison is the stems of both plants. The stems of Echeveria Pulvinata are pretty long.

The stems and petioles of this plant are the tallest in the entire Echeveria genus.

6. Flower size

Echeveria Harmsii and Pulvinata do not have large flowers. However, they have different sizes. Echeveria Harmsii has larger flowers. Their corollas reach a height of 3 cm. 

On the other hand, the corollas of Echeveria Pulvinata reach a height of 1.5 cm.

7. Flowering seasons

Both plants have similar flowers in terms of shape and color. Echeveria Harmsii and Pulvinata have small, bell-shaped, scarlet flowersHowever, they bloom in different seasons. The former blooms in spring, whereas the latter produces its flowers in winter.

Echeveria Harmsii vs. Pulvinata: Are they the same?

No, Echeveria Harmsii and Pulvinata are not the same plant. They have closely related Echeveria varieties. They have similar leaf colors, care requirements, and flowers. Both of them are drought-tolerant but not cold-hardy.

Their flowers are bright red with yellowish edges. However, many details in the leaves, stems, and flowers can help you identify each plant.

The leaves of both plants are the same length, but those of Echeveria Harmsii are a bit wider. As for the leaf shape, the leaves of Echeveria Harmsii are obovate, while those of Echeveria Pulvinata have oblanceolate leaves.

Another reliable identification mark is the stem. The Echeveria Pulvinata stems are way longer.

The flowering plants’ Echeveria Harmsii and Pulvinata are both flowering plants. They do, however, bloom at different times. The former blooms in the spring and the latter in the winter. Also, they vary in flower size.

Echeveria Harmsii flowers are nearly twice the size of Echeveria Pulvinata flowers. Lastly, the Echeveria Pulvinata plant looks denser than Harmsii, as it sheds its leaves without logical reason.

5/5 - (8 votes)